France : The World Leader in Public Spending

France: The World Leader in Public Spending

Caught between grandeur and fiscal imbalance, France walks a delicate line.

Debt and Deficit : Where Does France Stand?

A French Peculiarity in Public Finances

For decades, France has maintained a complex relationship with its public finances. While its social model is among the most protective in the world, it is also one of the most expensive. In 2025, France is recording a public deficit exceeding 5.8% of GDP—well above the 3% limit set by European treaties. By comparison, Germany hovers around 1.5%, and the Netherlands is close to budgetary balance.

France: The World Leader in Public Spending

A Debt Flirting with €3,350 Billion

France’s public debt has surpassed 115% of GDP, reaching approximately €3,350 billion. This means that each citizen bears an average debt of nearly €49,000. The situation is all the more concerning as interest rates continue to rise: the cost of servicing the debt could soon exceed the national education budget.

💬 "France is now borrowing at higher rates than Greece. A first since the eurozone crisis." – Le Monde, October 2024

Why Such a Situation?

Several factors explain France’s atypical position within the eurozone. First, a generous and centralized social model, built on a high level of redistribution. Pensions, healthcare, social assistance—public spending accounts for nearly 58% of GDP, the highest level in Europe. While this political choice reflects a commitment to strong social cohesion, it places a significant burden on the state’s finances. Second, a weak tradition of budgetary balance, shaped by decades of governance where stimulus was often prioritized over fiscal discipline. Unlike Germany, which enshrined the "schwarze Null" (zero deficit) rule in its Constitution, France has long treated deficit spending as a tool of economic policy rather than a risk to be contained. Finally, a series of successive crises—from the Yellow Vest protests to the COVID-19 pandemic, and more recently the energy tensions linked to the war in Ukraine—have justified massive support packages, pushing public debt even further.

Market Confidence in Question

For a long time, France enjoyed the confidence of investors, thanks to the strength of its institutions and the size of its economy. But in 2024, a turning point began to emerge. For the first time in over a decade, the interest rates at which France borrows have exceeded those of countries long considered more risky, such as Greece or Portugal.

Credit rating agencies are beginning to express concern. In April 2024, Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s signaled the possibility of a downgrade to France’s sovereign credit rating—an event that would automatically drive up borrowing costs. For a country already carrying public debt exceeding 110% of its GDP, this prospect is anything but trivial.

And Now?

The Austerity Dilemma

The government faces a Cornelian dilemma: reduce public spending to reassure the markets, or maintain its level of social protection at the risk of becoming further isolated within Europe. The current budgetary trajectory presented by Bercy aims for a return to a deficit below 3% by 2027. However, experts remain skeptical: economic growth is sluggish, social pressure is high, and fiscal room for maneuver is limited.

Between Legacy, Political Choices, and an Uncertain Future

France’s financial situation cannot be reduced to mere figures. It reflects a societal choice — that of a protective, yet costly, state. As Europe enters a new phase of fiscal discipline, France will have to choose: either undertake a deep reform of its model, or accept the price — both in the eyes of the markets and in public opinion.

“The grandeur of the French-style state comes at a cost. And the bill is now coming due.”

Find live updates on L'Horloge de la Dette Publique.